An NPR editor caught with child rape videos has gotten probation, after more than 100 people sent letters vouching for him. On the other side: one child pornography victim.
David Malokoff, who resigned as a science editor from NPR after being
arrested for child pornography, received just five years probation from
U.S. District Court Judge Ellen Huvelle, according to the Washington
Examiner.
Malakoff apparently claimed he possessed the videos of children being
assaulted for therapeutic reasons, trying to "relive his own rape" at
age nine. Judge Hevelle bought that defense, concluding that Malakoff
would be punished enough by his the "stigma" of his conviction.
According to the Examiner, over 100 of Malakoff's friends rallied
around him. Washington Post reporter Brigid Schulte wrote the court
asking for leniency, reports the paper, saying "He is an extraordinary
soul. Tormented, yes. But throughout the darkness, he radiates
goodness.... he does not deserve to be punished so severely a second
time."
Lining up against Malakoff's many friends and associates was a 19 year-old
survivor of child pornography. "I wish I could grow out of the pain,"
the girl wrote in a victim impact statement. "I wish it could fade away with age, but just like
those images are out there forever, those memories will always be with
me.... I pray that that seeing justice done will bring me some closure."
The Examiner story also questions Malakoff's story of childhood abuse.
"Defense attorneys provided a letter that Malakoff wrote in 1996 to a
childhood friend who Malakoff believed witnessed the rape," writes reporter Scott McCabe. "Malakoff
said he remembered playing in Rock Creek Park with friends... when a
strange man showed up and pulled him into the woods.
"The former neighbor wrote back that he recalled that the man abducted another boy, not Malakoff.
"'I can still hear the scream that followed his being led into the
woods,' the friend wrote. 'I can still feel the confusion and fear the
rest of us had as we looked on..."
Judge Huvelle is well-known in Washington for sentencing corrupt
lobbyist Jack Abramoff and Congressman Bob Ney to prison. She sentenced
a Maryland man to 14 years in prison in 2005 for identity theft crimes.
Another Beltway newsman faces a judge this week on child pornography
charges. Aaron Bruns, 29, a former Fox News producer, is scheduled to
be sentenced tomorrow.
The law enforcement news blog Tickle the Wire has the Malkoff sentencing memorandum.